And there goes another one, safely into hibernation until next September.
Reviewing a season of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. is always difficult because the show, from the outset, has always gone for a split season pattern, with a two/three month winter break, meaning that it basically functions as two mini-seasons, with changing themes from front to back half. It was especially so this year, with the first half being dedicated to rescuing Agent Simmons from the planet to which she got transported by the Monolith when season 2 ended, and the second to saving the Earth from Hive, the latest way to keep Brett Dalton in gainful employment on the show.
Basically, the show had a very good, very taut, deeply emotional first half which diffused rapidly once it came back out of cold storage.
Once again, I seem to be in a minority in enjoying Dalton’s cold, emotionless, very contained portrayal of Hive. There seems to be a low tolerance for anything that doesn’t at least nibble the scenery, but I’ve found it very effective.
Nevertheless, this year’s star has been Iain de Caestecker as Agent Fitz, who has been knocking it out of the stadium every single episode, not less in the second half than the first when he was driven every second by rescuing Simmons, and Will for her even after learning she had fallen in love with the latter.
So it’s been a particularly taut time in the back half when de Caestecker has been the rock on which the series has stood, and has finally got it together with Gemma (though he can’t yet quite believe his luck) and it’s been teased that he might have been for the chop.
Originally, this series was supposed to be about the Inhumans, and Daisy’s collecting the Secret Warriors. But, just as Marvel is now starting to row back on their determined push to have the Inhumans replace the X-Men as their leading franchise, that’s gone to the wall, and instead everything in the back half has been built up to her vision that someone on the team would die in an exploding shuttle. And you shall know them by their quite tasteful gold cross on a chain.
Said gold cross entered at the end of the penultimate week’s episode, donated to Mac. It duly bounced round half the team before settling upon Daisy, originator of such vision.
Now that would have been a bold and indeed dramatic ending, and I confess that it had been high in my thoughts. And her portrayal as a pawn of Hive and her piercing guilt for it seemed to leave her with nowhere to go except a conclusive and permanent redemption, and indeed the character herself was hellbent on that route.
But Chloe Bennett is an attractive young woman and let’s not pretend that that has no influence. Even though the Chekhovian gold cross ended up in her possession last, the show bottled on such a decision, and the Agent in the rocket doomed to explode turned out to be Lincoln.
This was a cowardly and disappointing choice, given that Luke Mitchell had only been in the cast this season, and had struggled to integrate with the team, but there was another death at the same time, which was more than due by this time: Hive was also killed, leaving Brett Dalton nowhere to go. Ever since he stunned everyone with the unforshadowed revelation that he was a double agent, the former Grant Ward has been a fascinating element of _S.H.I.E.L.D._, and they’re going to have to do a lot to replace him in season 4.
At least it wasn’t Fitz or Simmons. Elsewhere this season, I have had stern opinions (on which I will elaborate next week) about the manipulations of relationships on certain shows, and if this show, having carried the Fitz/Simmons story so successfully thus far had decided to snap it in two with the death of either character, it would have gone a long way towards destroying my anjoyment of the show.
The series ended with a ‘six months later’ flashforward to set up the new parameters for season 4. Dr Holden Radcliffe (a splendid, late season guest role for John Hannah, who would be welcome as a new regular in this quarter) has emerged from his heraings a vindicated man, and also a very successful one who’s about to introduce that long-term S.H.I.E.L.D. device, the Life Model Decoy.
Daisy has gone rogue, which is a completely logical development given her portrayal in the last couple of episodes, but also a regression to pre-Season 1 status when she was still Skye. She’s being hunted by Coulson and Mac, on the instructions of the Director, so at the very best Coulson’s suffered a demotion.
I wouldn’t get too attached to S.H.I.E.L.D. next season. It’s lost four cast members this year, two of them – Bobby and Hunter – very much to its detriment. ABC have already announced it’s to be pushed back form 9.00pm to 10.00pm on Tuesday nights, a slot everyone is describing as a ‘garbage fire’, so not conducive then. Add to this that ABC have definitely cancelled Agent Carter, whilst twice rejecting Most Wanted pilots (so much for spinning Annette Palicki and Lance Hunter into their own series), and it doesn’t argue much faith in the ongoing Marvel TV universe.
Nevertheless, I will be back for next year. It’s going to be very different, it seems, which has potential for both great new ideas or for utter disaster. At least I’m interested in finding out which it will be.